Free Starter Guide

Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese

Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese

Recipe At-A-Glance

Share this post:

Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese

Recipe At-A-Glance

Roasting the peppers helps mellow the spice and make this Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese the perfect (slightly spicy) comfort food!

Quick & Easy

Ready in 15 minutes

We have an ongoing debate in our house about grilled cheese. That’s normal right? Other families debate totally asinine things like this? Reassure me, please.

Anywho, I am a purist. I believe that for a grilled cheese to truly be considered a grilled cheese, it has to be in its simplest form. Bread. Cheese. Butter. Done.

My husband, on the other hand, thinks that any sandwich that happens to have melty cheese on it is considered a “grilled cheese.” No matter how much doctoring you do to it, it’s still a grilled cheese. I argue that it’s a slippery slope when you start calling any old sandwich with melted cheese a “grilled cheese.” I mean, what’s to stop people from calling a cheeseburger a “grilled cheese with beef.” Chaos. CHAOS, I SAY. Words mean something, people!

(For what it’s worth, I also consider chili a soup, and my husband thinks I’m crazy—he says it’s its own “thing.”)

Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese

I have been a simple grilled cheese evangelical for a few years now, and honestly, I’ll spew my rhetoric to anyone who will listen (which, really, isn’t many). I can be quite stubborn, actually.

And then I started working on this little recipe here, and something changed. I got a few loaves of the amazing White Bread Done Right from my friends at Dave’s Killer Bread (more on them in a sec), and the first thing I wanted to make with it was grilled cheese—so I did. A “me” grilled cheese. Bread. Cheese. Butter. And it was Awe. Some.

MY LATEST VIDEOS

White Bread Done Right is like everything I’ve ever wanted in a bread. It’s fluffy, light, and airy like white bread, but all the whole grains and nutrition of one of the whole grain cardboard-like breads from the grocery store. It’s perfect for grilled cheese (and French toast, too). This is whole grain bread that even whole grain bread haters will love.

Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese

This bread is so good that it actually made me want to doctor up my classic grilled cheese. Like I owed it to this bread to bring my A-game.

Man, I’m really showing you guys just how strange I am today, aren’t I?

So I started thinking about what bugged me about fancy/doctored/not-pure grilled cheeses, and I realized it was all about the focus of the sandwich. I believe the focus of a grilled cheese should be, you guessed it, the gooey, melty cheese (and good bread, of course). If that’s still the focus of your sandwich, even if you doctor it up, then I think I can get on board with calling your sandwich a “grilled cheese.” And so that’s why I’m calling this totally doctored up, totally fancy, totally not pure sandwich a grilled cheese. Because even though it’s full of jalapeños and bacon, it’s still all about the cheese.

Did you see me just rationalize away my principles? Boom.

Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese

Now I’ve taken you on the enchanted voyage through my thought process, let’s talk about this sandwich. Take the best jalapeño popper you’ve ever had and combine it with the best grilled cheese sandwich you’ve ever had, and you get this jalapeño popper grilled cheese. It’s super gooey, it’s a tiny bit spicy, it’s salty from the bacon, it’s crispy from a secret ingredient, and the whole thing is cooked in bacon grease. It’s, truthfully, incredible.

I know you’re probably thinking it is also spicy as all get out—after all, I call for a whole jalapeño for each grilled cheese sandwich. But actually, it’s pretty tame. To mellow the spice in jalapeños, the recipe has you roast them in a hot oven first. The heat brings out the sweetness of the peppers and milds the spice. If you like it a bit spicier, just keep the seeds and membranes intact in your jalapeños, or even skip the roasting step completely if you really like the heat.

Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese

This jalapeño popper grilled cheese is the first of a whole bunch of recipes I’ll be teaming up with Dave’s Killer Bread to bring you over the rest of the year. I am so excited to bring them on board to the Wholefully family! They are an incredible company with an awesome mission, and they make some seriously amazing products.

All of their bread is organic, non-GMO, packed with whole grains, and tasty as all get out. And their company is committed to Second Chance Employment—one-third of their employees have a criminal background. You can learn more about their Second Chance Employment program in this video.

I am just so proud to be partnering with Dave’s Killer Bread this year. If you want to track down your own loaf of White Bread Done Right (or any of their varieties), you can check out their store locator to find a retailer near you. Enjoy!
Print

Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese


  • Author: Cassie Johnston
  • Prep Time: 5 mins
  • Cook Time: 20 mins
  • Total Time: 25 minutes
  • Yield: 1 sandwich 1x

Description

Roasting the peppers helps mellow the spice and make this Jalapeño Popper Grilled Cheese the perfect (slightly spicy) comfort food!


Scale

Ingredients

  • 1 jalapeño pepper, stem, seeds, and membrane removed
  • 1 teaspoon olive oil
  • 2 slices bacon
  • 1 tablespoon butter
  • 2 slices Dave’s Killer Bread White Bread Done Right
  • 2 tablespoons cream cheese, softened
  • 1/2 cup shredded Monterey jack cheese
  • 2 tablespoons crushed tortilla chips (about 5 chips)

Instructions

  1. Preheat the oven to 450° (you can also do this in a toaster oven). Place the pepper, cut side up, on a small baking sheet, drizzle on the olive oil, and roast for 5-7 minutes, or until the pepper is softened and beginning to brown. Set aside to cool. Then dice into small pieces
  2. Meanwhile, cook the bacon in a heavy-bottom skillet (I recommend a cast iron skillet) over medium-high heat until crisp. Remove from pan, reserving the bacon grease in the pan. Crumble bacon and set aside.
  3. Melt the butter in the skillet with the bacon grease.
  4. Spread half of the cream cheese over one side of one slice of the bread. Place in the skillet, cream cheese side up. Then sprinkle with half of the Monterey jack cheese. Sprinkle on the roasted jalapeño, the bacon, and the tortilla chips. Then top with the remaining Monterey jack cheese.
  5. Spread the remaining half of the cream cheese over one side of the second slice of bread. Place it, cream cheese side down, on top of the sandwich. Press sandwich firmly with a spatula.
  6. Cook for 6-7 minutes, or until the cheese begins to melt and the bread is brown and crunchy, then flip and cook an additional 4-5 minutes. Serve immediately.

Notes

Always use gloves when handling hot peppers.

Jalapeños can vary greatly in heat level. Fresh jalapeños are milder than older ones. Peppers with smooth, uniform skin will be milder. If you see a pepper that is bumpy, lumpy, or has variations in the skin, it will probably be spicier. Roasting the peppers will balance out some of this heat variation, but not all of it. I’d recommend tasting the pepper before putting it on the sandwich just to make sure you didn’t pick up a scorcher!

Learn about my sponsored post policy in the bylaws. Want to be a sponsor? Let’s work together!

looking for more?Try these...

16 comments

Leave a Comment

  • Lisa SAYS

    Well, with apologies to your husband, you are right about grilled cheese.
    But I just can’t get on board with chili being called a soup. If anything, it is more like a stew. But really it’s just chili, in its own category, as your man says.
    So there. I agreed with both of you..
    Hope you are healing from your fall!

    • Cassie SAYS

      But if you HAD to put chili in a category, where would you put it? Like say, for example, you are organizing a cookbook into course-related sections—you wouldn’t just have a “chili” section would you? Wouldn’t it go with soups?

      (I told you I was stubborn. :))

      • Lisa SAYS

        Ahhh, well, cooksbooks often call it “soups and stews.” Sometimes even “soups, stews, and chilis”! But if you had a cookbook with only “soups,” I will concede there would be nowhere else to put chili. But I would find that cookbook to be discriminating and pigeonholing ;)

  • Pinned. Great idea with the flavors. I have no doubt my husband will be messaging you soon with praise and thanks. :)

  • L.D. SAYS

    Chili n’ grilled cheese is a match made in heaven, grilled cheese is a bare canvas like chili, you can paint or build it any ol’ way ya wunna..Now on the debate of whether chili is a soup or a stew well, out here on the western plains I’ve been known to put black bean, pinto, kidney with ground turkey in my crockpot chili but, in Texas if you just park a can of beans near their so-called chili you’ll be hung by the nearest tree or burnt at the stake with a pile of mesquite bush, I actually think it’s a felony to put beans in chili in Texas. To me that’s just a chili sauce to slather on hot dogs, right? Adios n’ Hasta La Bye Bye L.D.

    • Cassie SAYS

      Now, I’m more of a grilled cheese and tomato soup kinda gal. I serve my chili with noodles, cheese, crackers, and sour cream! :) And I often put THREE kinds of beans in my chili. Texas would hate me.

  • debbie in alaska SAYS

    I’m somewhere between you both. If the main ingredient is cheese and you add elements to kick it up a notch (bacon, prosciutto, sundried tomatoes, carmalized onion, basil, etc) than I consider it a fancy (and delicious!) grilled cheese. But if there is more of the extras than there is of the cheese, it’s something else.

    • Cassie SAYS

      Now I really want a grilled cheese with bacon, prosciutto, sundried tomatoes, caramelized onions, and basil. Ha!

  • I love Dave’s Killer bread! Been buying it for years. The only bread we basically eat. And the story behind it is amazing.

  • Karla SAYS

    I tend to be a purist too but this looks amazing.
    I’d never heard of Dave’s Killer Bread but I looked up where to buy it in my area and several stores have it. Can’t wait to try it!

  • Lisa SAYS

    I found your blog through a pretty Pinterest pic and I’m so glad I did — you have a great blog! Beautiful pictures, and very well written – keep it up :) Looking forward to reading more of your posts!

  • Emma Handziuk SAYS

    My husband is also Canadian and has the same issue of calling anything with melted cheese a “grilled cheese”….

  • Rachel SAYS

    I used pickled jalapeños instead of roasting my own…so good! Thanks for the idea!!

Join the Conversation (16 Comments)

Skip to toolbar